Interest Only vs P&I: How to Choose the Right Home Loan

Interest Only vs P&I: How to Choose the Right Home Loan

Principal and interest (P&I) is the better default for most borrowers. Every repayment reduces the loan, and you pay less interest overall. Interest only (IO) keeps repayments lower for a set period, usually up to five years, but the balance does not fall. When the period ends, repayments rise. IO can suit an investor with a clear plan for that jump. It is a poor fit for a borrower who is simply stretching to afford a property. Below is how each option works, what it costs over time, and how to test your own numbers before you commit.

WealthstackerPut Loan Choices in ContextCompare property strategies with WealthStacker’s investment toolkit, using AI tools and personalized modeling to assess potential net worth in real time.Visit

TL;DR

  • Interest only: you pay just the interest for a set period, so the loan balance stays where it was and your repayments rise when the period ends.
  • Principal and interest: each repayment pays down some of the debt, so repayments start higher but the loan shrinks from day one.
  • Total cost: on the same rate and term, an IO period costs more interest overall. In the example below, five years of IO on a $500,000 loan adds roughly $37,000.
  • Investors: IO can maximise tax-deductible interest and free up cash, but only works if you plan for the step-up, a sale or a refinance.
  • Before you choose: test the repayment at the higher P&I figure, not the IO one.

Table of Contents

How the two repayment types work

With a P&I loan, each repayment covers the interest charged for the period plus a slice of the amount you borrowed. Early on, most of each payment is interest. Over time the share going to principal grows, and by the end of the term the loan is repaid in full.

With an IO loan, your repayments cover only the interest. According to Moneysmart, you pay nothing off the amount borrowed for the set period, so the balance doesn’t reduce. At the end of the period the loan changes to P&I, and repayments are higher.

That last point catches people out. The remaining balance has to be repaid over a shorter remaining term. A 30-year loan with five years of IO means the full balance is repaid over the last 25 years. You are not just paying principal for the first time. You are paying it on a compressed schedule.

Two practical details are worth knowing:

  • Terms are limited. Lenders typically cap the IO period at five years, according to an RBA speech on interest-only lending. Your lender decides whether to offer it to you at all.
  • Pricing can differ. IO loans can carry a higher interest rate than P&I loans, so the repayment gap is not purely the principal you skip. Moneysmart lists a higher rate as one of the risks.

What the difference looks like in dollars

Moneysmart’s worked example shows the shape of it. An interest-only loan starts at $2,010 a month and rises to $3,250 at the end of the IO period. A P&I loan with constant repayments of $2,875 was the better fit for that example borrower. The IO loan feels cheaper for years, then costs more every month than the P&I loan would have.

Here is a simple illustration you can check yourself. Take a $500,000 loan over 30 years at 6% p.a., with the same rate under both options. This is our own arithmetic, not a lender quote.

P&I for 30 years 5 years IO, then P&I for 25 years
Monthly repayment, years 1 to 5 about $2,998 $2,500
Monthly repayment, years 6 to 30 about $2,998 about $3,222
Balance after 5 years about $465,000 $500,000
Total interest over 30 years about $579,000 about $616,000

You save around $498 a month for five years. In return you pay about $37,000 more interest and then carry a repayment around $224 a month higher than the P&I loan, for 25 years. If the IO loan also carries a higher rate, the gap widens.

Repayments are not the only difference. Under P&I you have paid down about $35,000 of the debt after five years. Under IO you have paid down nothing. If the property has not risen in value, Moneysmart notes you won’t have built any equity. That leaves you exposed in a market downturn or if your circumstances change.

What the difference looks like in dollars

Why the step-up matters more than the starting repayment

The repayment that counts is the one after the IO period, not the one on the first statement. An RBA paper on mortgage products explains that IO loans convert to P&I automatically, usually after five to ten years. If they are not refinanced into another IO loan, repayments jump and can cause distress.

The RBA’s Christopher Kent has made the behavioural point plainly. If a borrower spends the extra cash flow during the IO period, they face a sizeable adjustment when it ends. That means finding more income or cutting spending. A borrower with no provisions may even have to sell the property.

A useful habit is to treat the IO saving as money with a job. Either send the difference to a mortgage offset account or save it for the step-up. If you are weighing those options, our guide to offset vs redraw explains how they work and the tax risks to watch.

When interest only can make sense

IO is a tool, and it has legitimate uses. The sensible ones share a feature: a plan for the end date.

Investors weighing tax and cash flow

For housing investors, the key motivation is that IO maximises interest expenses, which are tax deductible for investors, and it frees up funds for other investments. Lower repayments can also take pressure off the cash flow of a negatively geared property.

Tax treatment depends on your situation, including how the loan is used and whether the property produces income. Check the detail with a registered tax agent or accountant before you structure a loan around deductions. If you are comparing loan structures for an investment, our piece on owner-occupier vs investor loans covers how lenders treat each.

Short-term cash flow squeezes

IO is not only for investors. Kent notes that for people buying a home to live in, IO offers flexibility. It can help households through a temporary period of reduced income or higher spending, such as raising children, a big renovation or bridging finance. It can also suit people without steady income, such as the self-employed.

The word to hold onto is temporary. IO works as a bridge when you know what is on the other side of it.

A planned sale or refinance

If you intend to sell before the IO period ends, you never face the higher repayments. If you plan to refinance, remember a new lender will assess you again. APRA’s guidance says a prudent lender will do a fresh serviceability assessment when you change between P&I and IO. Rolling over is not automatic, and it depends on your income and debts at the time.

When P&I is the stronger choice

P&I tends to suit you if:

  • The home is your own. You want to own it outright, and building equity is the point.
  • Budget is tight now. If the IO saving is what makes the repayments affordable, the P&I figure is the one you can actually afford. The IO figure is only a delay.
  • You want to minimise interest. Moneysmart’s risk list flags paying more over the life of the loan as a core IO risk.
  • You expect to hold long term. The longer you keep the loan, the more the IO period costs.
  • You like predictability. There is no step-up to plan around.

P&I also works for investors. Paying down the debt builds equity you can use later, and it removes the risk of a repayment jump landing in a year when rates or your income have moved against you.

How lenders assess each option

Lender rules for IO have shifted over the years, and they explain why IO is not always available.

In March 2017, APRA told lenders that IO loans must be restricted to 30 per cent of new residential mortgage lending. It also planned internal limits on IO loans at high loan-to-value ratios. APRA removed the limit in December 2018, saying the policy had served its purpose.

Since then, lenders set their own policies. Kent notes that prudent lenders assess your ability to make both interest and principal payments. APRA’s serviceability expectations are based on the P&I payments over the term remaining after the IO period. In practice, a lender will usually test whether you can afford the higher repayment, not just the IO one.

How lenders assess each option

In 2019, APRA stopped expecting lenders to use a fixed minimum assessment rate of 7 per cent. Lenders can now set their own floor and apply a buffer of at least 2.5 per cent over the loan’s rate. Your borrowing capacity is tested at a rate well above what you will actually pay. It makes sense to run your own version of that test. Our guide to interest rate stress testing walks through eight checks.

Five checks before you choose

  1. Find the post-IO repayment. Calculate the P&I repayment over the remaining term, not the full term. Compare it to your income today and your likely income then.
  2. Compare rates, not just repayment types. An IO rate can sit above the P&I rate for the same loan. Ask what the rate is on each, and what the fees are.
  3. Decide what the saving is for. Offset account, buffer, other investments, or lifestyle. Only the first three hold up when the period ends.
  4. Stress the rate. Add 2 to 3 percentage points to your rate and see whether the P&I repayment still fits your budget. This mirrors how lenders assess you.
  5. Plan the exit. Decide now whether you will sell, refinance or switch to P&I, and what has to be true for each.

If you want a person to review the structure, a licensed mortgage broker or your accountant can help. Our guide to mortgage broker vs bank covers how broker commissions and the best interests duty work.

Test both options against your own plan

A generic comparison tells you how IO and P&I behave. It cannot tell you which one fits your numbers. That depends on your income, your other debts, how long you will hold the property and what you will do with the cash you free up.

WealthStacker is built for that kind of question. It offers free automated quarterly property valuations, borrowing power estimations and 15-year modelling tools for comparing rentvesting and buying scenarios. Its goal and net worth planners let you see how the same decision plays out in your wealth over time. You can start on the WealthStacker toolkit and model your property plan without a spreadsheet.

Wealthstacker

For a deeper side-by-side on this exact choice, read our interest only vs principal and interest guide.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Choosing IO because the first repayment looks affordable. If you could not afford the P&I repayment, the step-up will be a problem.
  • Spending the difference. As the RBA warns, unspent provisions make the end of the period easier, and spent ones make it harder.
  • Assuming you can roll over. A new IO period is a new application, assessed on your situation at the time.
  • Counting on price growth. If the property does not rise in value, you have no extra equity from the IO period.
  • Ignoring total cost. The lower repayment is a timing benefit. The extra interest is the price of it.

FAQ

Is interest only or principal and interest better?

Neither is better for everyone. P&I costs less in total interest and builds equity from the first repayment, so it suits most owner-occupiers. IO can suit investors who want to maximise deductible interest, or borrowers with a temporary cash flow squeeze and a clear exit plan.

Is an interest-only loan cheaper?

It is cheaper month to month during the IO period, and more expensive overall. You pay more total interest because the balance is not reduced, and the IO rate can be higher than the P&I rate. In the example above, five years of IO added about $37,000 in interest on a $500,000 loan.

What happens when the interest-only period ends?

The loan switches to P&I, and you start repaying the amount borrowed as well as interest. Repayments are higher because the balance must be repaid over the remaining term. You can ask your lender about another IO period, but that is a fresh assessment and is not guaranteed.

Can I switch between interest only and P&I?

Often yes, but your lender will usually reassess you. APRA’s guidance describes a new serviceability assessment when you change between the two. Talk to your lender or a broker about the process and any fees.

Sources

Recommended